There uesd to be 反义疑问句的回答是什么样的?提问部分,国内英语教学界大多支持didn't there/usedn't there?但是回答呢,是不是Yes, there did. No, there didn't.?

来源:学生作业帮助网 编辑:作业帮 时间:2024/05/08 14:15:02
There uesd to be 反义疑问句的回答是什么样的?提问部分,国内英语教学界大多支持didn't there/usedn't there?但是回答呢,是不是Yes, there did. No, there didn't.?

There uesd to be 反义疑问句的回答是什么样的?提问部分,国内英语教学界大多支持didn't there/usedn't there?但是回答呢,是不是Yes, there did. No, there didn't.?
There uesd to be 反义疑问句的回答是什么样的?
提问部分,国内英语教学界大多支持didn't there/usedn't there?
但是回答呢,是不是Yes, there did. No, there didn't.?

There uesd to be 反义疑问句的回答是什么样的?提问部分,国内英语教学界大多支持didn't there/usedn't there?但是回答呢,是不是Yes, there did. No, there didn't.?
楼主的这个问题其实在国内已经争论很久了,我曾经还看过几篇针对这个问题的论文.
其实支持didn't there/usedn't there还有wasn't there的观点都有.
我们知道反义疑问句都是找出问句中的动词,根据其时态等的不同将其改变形式,那么支持前者显然是将句子中的used to 这个词组当作主要谓语结构,反义疑问句改成didn't there?那么回答也就是Yes there did.No,there didn't.
而支持后者的则是将这个句子的主要架构看作there be句型,反义疑问句则是wasn't there?
不过目前为止,赞同第一个观点的更为普遍.

there used to be的反意疑问句有两种形式,如下: 1. didn't there? 2. usedn't there?

was
was't